Salted Caramel Ice Cream (Vegan)

Vegan salted caramel ice cream. My husband said this is the best ice cream he's EVER eaten. And that man's eaten a lot of ice cream in his day.I wish I could get this blog written from O’s perspective.. but I already spend so much of my day saying “Write your blog, honey! Write your blog! Seriously.. write your blog!”

….and yet, there’s only oh, two posts on his sports blog. So I’m going to have to take this one over. But if O were writing? It’d go a little something like this.

“OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG OMG this is the greatest thing I’ve ever eaten.” Except maybe, just maybe, slightly less tween-girly and a little more.. lawyery. 

Vegan salted caramel ice cream. My husband said this is the best ice cream he's EVER eaten. And that man's eaten a lot of ice cream in his day.loves this ice cream. I mean, I thought I love caramel, right? Especially salted caramel. Especially salted caramel ice cream. Most especially super love vegan salted caramel ice cream.. Right? But nothing can compare to O’s love of this stuff. And I don’t blame him.

It’s good.

The texture is so rich and creamy–not at all icy or lacking–but perfectly smooth and buttery. The caramel is sweet and complex, the slight saltiness balancing the richness beautifully, the swirl of caramel adding to the overall indulgence. I was a little shocked at how this turned out myself, considering how many batches of vegan ice cream I’ve trashed due their total lack of resemblance to real, honest-to-goodness ice cream. Eating something a bit healthier yet a little less delicious is OK from time to time, but salted caramel ice cream is not one of those occasions.

Vegan salted caramel ice cream. My husband said this is the best ice cream he's EVER eaten. And that man's eaten a lot of ice cream in his day.I whipped up my easy go-to caramel sauce but used a cashew-and-almond-milk blend in place of heavy cream to make it vegan. I blended a generous amount into my ultimate favorite vegan ice cream base and then swirled in some more, just because I can. Because I’m a grown up who gets to decide how much or how little salted caramel she eats. And the decision is..

lots. I get to eat lots of it. 

Vegan salted caramel ice cream. My husband said this is the best ice cream he's EVER eaten. And that man's eaten a lot of ice cream in his day.O, however, surpasses my proclivity for this stuff pretty impressively. We hopped into Ben & Jerry’s the other day, as I am obsessed with the salted caramel & blonde brownie ice cream (in the dipped cones, I mean, come on, people! I can’t say no) and he threw his cone away, because he thought it was nowhere near as good as mine. I wouldn’t go quite that far, but you’ve got to give him credit, right? And to be fair, my version is made of cashews and coconut milk, maple syrup and coconut oil (and, OK, a little regular white sugar, too), which can’t be said of anything you’d find at your average ice cream shop. 

He got pretty upset, too, when we ran out of this stuff. When I made a batch of Speculoos and Earl Grey ice cream with a Cookie Butter swirl, he was annoyed! Because it wasn’t more vegan salted caramel ice cream. Then, of course, he tasted the new batch, and all was forgiven. But that’s another story for another day.

Vegan salted caramel ice cream. My husband said this is the best ice cream he's EVER eaten. And that man's eaten a lot of ice cream in his day.The moral of today’s diatribe? Make this. Your husband will become a vegan salted caramel ice cream monster. But that’s OK.. just one more little thing he couldn’t live without. Right? How very Ina Garten of us.

Salted Caramel Ice Cream (Vegan)
Rich and creamy, deeply sweet and just slightly salty, this salted caramel ice cream is painfully delicious and just happens to be vegan.
Recipe type: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Serves: 6
  • Salted caramel sauce:
  • ½ cup unsweetened almond milk
  • ½ cup + 2 tablespoons water, divided
  • 1 cup cashews
  • 1½ cups sugar
  • ½ cup water
  • 3 tablespoons Earth Balance
  • 2 teaspoons flake sea salt
  • Ice cream:
  • 1 14-ounce can full-fat coconut milk (don't sub light coconut milk here!)
  • 1 cup cashews, soaked at least 6 hours
  • 3 tablespoons coconut oil
  • 2 cups salted caramel sauce, divided
  1. Make your "heavy cream": blend ½ cup almond milk, 2 tablespoons water, and 1 cup cashews in high-speed blender until very, very smooth. Sieve or press through a nut milk bag for the smoothest texture.
  2. Make your salted caramel sauce: Stir sugar and ½ cup water in heavy large saucepan over medium-low heat until sugar dissolves. Increase heat; boil without stirring until syrup turns golden (I advise to not wait until it turns amber, as that usually means it's burnt!), occasionally brushing down sides of pan with pastry brush dipped into water and swirling pan, about 12 minutes. Remove from heat. Whisk in Earth Balance. Very gradually add cream (mixture will bubble vigorously). Stir over low heat until smooth. Add 2 teaspoons sea salt. Makes about 2 cups.
  3. Combine coconut milk, 1 cup soaked cashews, coconut oil, and 1½ cups salted caramel sauce in a high-speed blender. Blend until very smooth. Transfer to air-tight container and refrigerate until very cold. Once the mixture is cold, churn according to ice cream maker instructions.
  4. Once churned, the ice cream will have the texture of frozen yogurt. Gently swirl in the remaining ½ cup salted caramel sauce and place in freezer at least 2-3 hours.


Breakfast Pizza (vegan). Whole wheat pita, salty pistachios, and fruity, gooey jam. So versatile and perfectly satisfying in the morning!

Breakfast Pita Pizza (Vegan)

Pizza in the morning, pizza in the evening.. (everybody now!) pizza at suppertime! When pizza’s on a..  Except I’m going to go ahead and assume that if you’ve happened upon my blog, you’re probably not one to scarf down a box of Bagel Bites for dinner. Or breakfast. Or ever.  But when it comes to… 

Read More »

Stone Fruit Skillet Crumble for Two. Vegan, Gluten Free, and No Refined Sugars!

Stone Fruit Skillet Crumble for Two (Vegan, Gluten Free, Refined Sugar Free)

I’ve been terrible about wishing away summer lately. Maybe it’s the triple-digit heat and the, yes, triple-digit humidity; maybe it’s being forced to run on the treadmill or else; maybe it’s the bird-like mosquitoes we have hovering over our yard at all times. Whatever it is, I’m dreaming of pumpkin spice lattes (vegan recipe coming soon!) and… 

Read More »


Matcha Granola with Blueberries

How much do I love matcha? Well, how much time do you have? Ever since I knew it was a “thing”, I’ve gone with matcha-anything at every given chance: tempura green tea mochi at the ramen bar, matcha lattes at the Midtown coffee shop, tiny bags of the good stuff at the Asian market to take… 

Read More »

Peanut Spinach Udon. These noodles are perfect for lunch and are great warm, room temp, AND cold. Vegan & gluten-free option

Peanut Spinach Udon (Vegan)

I’m terrible about lunches. Half the time, I end up eating some augmented instant ramen, whisking in sesame oil and fresh ginger to boiling water, plopping a few faux chicken broth cubes in with the whole mix. Poaching an egg, maybe, and leaving it at that. At least I throw out the little foil packet… 

Read More »

Mango mojito smoothie. Literally, summer in a glass. Creamy, frothy, sweet, fresh.. just perfect.

Mango Mojito Smoothie

In the winter, I dream of summer. Of long nights spent belly-laughing outdoors with friends, of oversized margaritas and overflowing molcajetes of creamy guacamole, of chasing fireflies but being too scared to touch one. All of which happens frightfully infrequently, come summer. Instead, my days look like this: check weather forecast for any hint of… 

Read More »

The simplest ever raspberries and cream: tart, juicy raspberries and sweet, creamy sweetened condensed milk. Too delicious not to share.

Raspberries and Cream

Some recipes are so simple, they’re almost embarrassing to post (memories of the recipe-in-a-description yet oh so delicious peanut butter banana toast with agave and sea salt) yet too delicious not to. What if there’s a French major in Montana who’s never tried it? A stay-at-home mom in Colorado who’d never thought to pair the simple… 

Read More »

Dark Chocolate Cherry Smores. These are simply amazing! Give s'mores a grown-up flair with rich dark chocolate and ripe fresh cherries. Mmm.

Dark Chocolate Cherry S’mores

Did you know Sunday, August 10 was National S’mores Day? I did. If I were a clever blogger, I’d have posted this recipe then. But I’m not. I’m a woops-that-happened blogger who at least comes up with some damn good s’mores. So I figure that makes up for it, right? My ultimate all-time favorite s’mores are… 

Read More »

Vegan Alfredo Sauce - The perfect vegan alfredo sauce using Tofutti Better Than Cream Cheese

Vegan Alfredo Sauce

Even since I was a kid, I’ve never been one of those people who squealed over pasta primavera, who even ordered a reasonable marinara, who ever got excited a cheesy baked ziti. Nope, it’s alfredo all. the. way. for me. Which is unfortunate seeing as how, you know, it’s laden with cheese, cream, and butter, none of which… 

Read More »

Summer Polenta Bowl with chimichurri. Full of fresh summer veggies, this one-bowl meal is healthy, hearty, and totally delicious.

Summer Polenta Bowl (Vegan Option)

What is it about bowls-with-a-lot-of-stuff that are so appealing to us? O and me, specifically, I guess, but perhaps people in general, as well? There’s just something so hearty and comforting about a bowl layered with generous servings of vibrant, seasonal veggies and proteins that we can’t get over. Enter, the summer polenta bowl. Pretty… 

Read More »

Vegan Peach Ice Cream. 7 ingredients, no refined sugars, no gluten. Just tons of peaches and coconut milk and summery goodness!

Vegan Peach Ice Cream

I have strong, fond memories of peach ice cream, mostly stemming from homemade batches throughout my childhood.. most notably the one time my sister kept inching closer and closer to my uncle and the old-fashioned “crank” style machine. She leaned just a little too close, he wasn’t paying attention, and WHAM! She tidied up the whole… 

Read More »